Is Your Grill’s Built-In Thermometer Accurate?

Your grill’s lid thermometer might be off by 75 degrees or more. Here’s why, and how to find out how hot your grill really is where the food cooks.

Last Updated:
Is Your Grill’s Built-In Thermometer Accurate?

Table of Contents

You fire up the grill, close the lid, and wait for the dial to hit the right number. But is that number actually telling you the truth?

We put it to the test. Our grill's built-in thermometer read 250°F. A surface thermometer sitting right on the grates read 325°F. Same grill, same moment, and a 75-degree difference.

Why the Built-In Thermometer Gets It Wrong

The thermometer on your grill's lid measures the air at the top of the grill, not the grates where your food is cooking. Those two spots can be very different temperatures.

Heat doesn't spread evenly inside a grill. Depending on your grill and how your fire is set up, the lid can read hotter or cooler than the cooking surface. On some grills, the gap can be well over 100 degrees.

And that gap doesn't stay the same. Wind, cold weather, and rain can all cool the lid, which throws off the reading even more. So even if you know your dial runs "about 50 off," that number can change from one cook to the next.

Why It Matters

A 75-degree difference changes everything about how your food cooks. If you think your grill is at 250°F but the grates are really at 325°F, your food will cook faster and darker than you planned. Chicken skin can burn before the meat is done, and low-and-slow cooks won't be so low and slow.

Recipes and cook times are based on the temperature where the food sits. If you're going off the lid, you're guessing.

How to Tell How Hot Your Grill Really Is

  1. Measure at the grates. Set a grill surface thermometer right on the cooking grate where your food will go. Give it a few minutes to settle, then read it with the lid closed or through a quick peek.
  2. Compare it to your lid. Check both readings at the same time. Now you know how far off your built-in dial is, at least for that cook.
  3. Check your hot and cool zones. Move the surface thermometer around the grill. Most grills have hot spots, and knowing where they are helps you place your food.
  4. Check your food, too. The grill temperature tells you how fast your food is cooking. An instant-read thermometer tells you when it's done. You need both.

Want a Better Lid Thermometer?

If you'd rather keep watching the lid, you can swap out the built-in dial for a more accurate one. The Maverick Professional Thermocouple Grill Thermometer is designed to replace standard analog grill thermometers. It reads from 32°F to 842°F, and its backlit display is easy to see day or night.

Even with an upgraded dial, it's still measuring at the lid. A surface thermometer at the grates is the best way to know the temperature where your food actually cooks.

The Tool That Makes It Easy

We used a Maverick Surface Thermometer in our test. It sits right on your grill grates or in a cast iron pan, reads from 150°F to 700°F, and is made of stainless steel and glass to handle the heat.

The Bottom Line

Your grill's built-in thermometer isn't telling you the whole story. It measures the air in the lid, not the heat where your food cooks. Put a surface thermometer on the grates, compare the two, and you'll never have to guess again.

So have you ever tested your grill's thermometer?

How to Make an Iced Latte Without an ...

No espresso machine? No problem. Learn how to brew rich stovetop es...
Read More